Mutz Pizzeria – North Shore’s Must-Try Pizza Spot

Mutz Pizzeria in Middleton, MA, is the real deal. Run by the TikTok legend himself—Marco the Pizza Man—this spot is a must-visit for any pizza lover. If you’ve ever caught his TikTok Live, you know how fun it is to watch him make orders in real time, and visiting in person only adds to the experience.

We ordered a variety of pizzas to put Mutz to the test:
🍕 Buffalo Chicken (“Boofalo Chicken”)– A solid take on a classic, packed with flavor and just the right amount of kick. You can get blue cheese or ranch on the side to dip it in. 🍕 Mushroom & Garlic (“Fungi”) – My personal favorite because they don’t skimp on the garlic—every bite was packed with bold, savory goodness.
🍕 Sausage & Ricotta – The creamy ricotta balanced the sausage perfectly, making for a rich and indulgent slice.
🍕 Pizzaman’s Favorite (Banana Pepper & Pepperoni) – A genius combo of tangy heat and salty goodness that just works.

Each pizza was cooked to perfection—crispy crust, well-balanced toppings, and none of that excessive grease you find on so many North Shore Greek-style pizzas. And the best part? The prices are reasonable: $15 for a cheese pizza and $18 for specialty pies.

One unexpected win? The house-made ranch. I’m not usually a big ranch person, but I have to give props—it’s fresh and clearly made with care.

The ambiance is also a vibe. The pink theme, Post Malone references, and foosball table** give it a cool, laid-back energy. It’s a to-go-only spot with no seating, but the open-concept setup lets you see everything happening, which adds to the charm.

Mutz Pizzeria delivers on quality, taste, and atmosphere. Marco says it best: More pizza, less drama. And honestly, with pizza this good, that’s all you need.

🔥 Final Ratings:

• Food: 9/10 🍕
• Ambiance: 7/10 (Cool pink theme, Post Malone, and foosball table, but no seating)
• Affordability: 7/10 (Great quality for the price)